Former NYT Reporter Egan Opines on GOP’s ‘Need for Greed’ to Pass Ryan’s ‘Radical’ Medicare Plan
Tuesday’s New York Times featured a rare excursion into print by Timothy Egan, liberal Times reporter turned leftist nytimes.com blogger, excoriating Republicans like Rep. Paul Ryan and the “Tea Party political illiterates” as greed-heads for wanting to reform the bankrupt Medicare system: ” The Need for Greed .” The bet was audacious from the beginning, and given the miserable, low-down tenor of contemporary politics, not unfathomable: Could you divide the country between greedy geezers and everyone else as a way to radically alter the social contract? But in order for the Republican plan to turn Medicare, one of most popular government programs in history, into a much-diminished voucher system, t he greed card had to work . The plan’s architect, Representative Paul Ryan of Wisconsin, drew a line in the actuarial sand: Anyone born before 1957 would not be affected. They could enjoy the single-payer, socialized medical care program that has allowed millions of people to live extended lives of dignity and decent health care. And their kids and grandkids? Sorry, they would have to take their little voucher and pay some private insurer nearly twice as much as a senior pays for basic government coverage today. In essence, Republicans would break up the population between an I’ve Got Mine segment and The Left Behinds. Egan claims but doesn't offer evidence (beyond polling in a strange special election in New York State and a handy Newt Gingrich quote) that “This plan is toast.”
Posted by
on May 17, 2011. Filed under